EI
EIDP, Inc. (CTA-PA)·Q4 2016 Earnings Summary
Executive Summary
- Q4 2016 net sales were $5.21B, down 2% year over year; operating EPS rose 89% to $0.51 and GAAP EPS was $0.29 as cost savings and currency benefits offset Agriculture timing headwinds .
- Segment operating margins expanded by 305 bps in Q4, led by Performance Materials (+275 bps) and Nutrition & Health (+615 bps), while Protection Solutions contracted ~60 bps on lower plant utilization .
- FY16 free cash flow improved $1.6B to $2.28B; net debt fell to $2.57B by year-end on stronger cash generation and lower capex .
- Guidance: Q1 2017 GAAP EPS expected down ~18% y/y (includes ~$0.15 merger costs), but operating EPS up ~8% y/y; merger with Dow expected to close in 1H17 pending approvals—key stock catalyst .
What Went Well and What Went Wrong
What Went Well
- “We exceeded our expectations for earnings, cost savings, operating margin expansion and free cash flow improvement” in 2016; merger integration planning progressing, with closing targeted for 1H17 (CEO Ed Breen) .
- Performance Materials: Q4 operating earnings +17% to $328M on lower product costs, cost savings, and global auto demand; margins expanded ~275 bps .
- Nutrition & Health: Q4 operating earnings +59% to $135M aided by cost savings and a $27M asset sale; operating margin improved ~615 bps; 14th consecutive quarter of y/y margin improvement .
What Went Wrong
- Agriculture: Q4 net sales -10% to $1.39B as route-to-market change in the southern U.S. shifted ~$200M seed shipments into Q1 2017; despite a $78M currency tailwind, timing reduced Q4 sales and operating earnings .
- Protection Solutions: Q4 operating earnings -3% to $142M as cost savings were more than offset by higher unit costs from lower plant utilization and currency headwinds; margin contracted ~60 bps .
- Significant items: Q4 included pre-tax charges of $(557)M (ERP impairment $(435)M, transaction costs $(164)M), driving GAAP-to-operating EPS adjustments of $(0.44) per share; non-operating pension/OPEB curtailment gain provided $0.29 per share benefit .
Financial Results
Consolidated Metrics (USD)
Segment Net Sales ($B)
Segment Operating Earnings ($M)
KPIs
Guidance Changes
Earnings Call Themes & Trends
Management Commentary
- Ed Breen, CEO: “2016 was an important year for DuPont as we exceeded our expectations for earnings, cost savings, operating margin expansion and free cash flow improvement… We now expect the merger to close in the first half of 2017, pending regulatory approval.” .
- Q4 outlook drivers: Operating EPS growth driven by cost savings and reversal of seed delivery timing to Q1; GAAP EPS includes ~$0.15 merger transaction costs .
- Balance sheet & cash priorities: ~$1.3B dividends planned for 2017; capex aligned with D&A; FY16 share repurchases $916M (~13M shares) .
Q&A Highlights
The full Q4 2016 earnings call transcript was not available in our document corpus; we relied on the press release and earnings slides for qualitative insights. The call webcast details and replay were provided (8:00 AM ET; replay passcode 6670063#) .
Estimates Context
- S&P Global consensus (EPS and revenue) was unavailable for CTA-PA in our SPGI mapping at this time. Values retrieved from S&P Global were unavailable.
- External consensus reference: Zacks/Nasdaq reported Q4 operating EPS consensus of $0.42; DuPont delivered $0.51, a beat of $0.09, while sales were “slightly shy” of consensus (exact revenue consensus not provided) .
Key Takeaways for Investors
- Operating execution remains strong: broad-based margin expansion, cost savings ahead of plan, and cash generation inflection ($2.28B FCF) support de-leveraging and shareholder returns .
- Agriculture timing is transitory: ~$200M seed shipment shift depressed Q4 but should lift Q1 2017 operating EPS ~8% y/y; watch U.S. corn-to-soy shift as a partial headwind .
- Auto end-market strength continues to underpin Performance Materials, offsetting price pass-through pressures; monitor raw material pricing and planned Q2 ethylene mini-turnaround .
- E&C resilience: Solamet® momentum offsets PV/Tedlar® weakness; innovation cadence remains a lever amid mixed electronics demand .
- Merger with Dow is the catalyst: closing targeted for 1H17; transaction costs weigh on GAAP EPS near term, but synergy and portfolio actions should drive medium-term rerating .
- Near-term trading: Expect Q1 2017 operating EPS lift versus y/y on timing reversal and cost actions; GAAP EPS optics negative from merger charges—focus on non-GAAP trajectory .